MMM research desk · study document

9:30 AM to 11:30 AM Testing Studies

Everything tested on the New York morning, the two hours Max trades: when the high and low are made, what the 09:30 and 10:00 MMM candles tell you, the opening range, the opening gaps, and how far a run of body closes goes before the other side closes. In one document, in plain words.

Updated Oct 28 2026Market NQ / MNQ futuresData 763 days (2022–25) + 61 days (2026)Window 09:30–11:30 New York
The morning is made early

The high or the low of 09:30–11:30 is in by 10:00 on 83 / 85% of days. The first 15 minutes make about a third of them.

BC+ points the way

A BC+ at 09:30 or at 10:00: the next candle takes its target first 82–92% of the time, on every timeframe.

The opening range breaks once

Price closes out of 09:30–10:00 on 94 / 92% of days and runs a median 51 / 71 pts. It breaks both sides only 14 / 11%.

Gaps with the 4H side hold

09:30–10:00 gaps get touched in about 5 minutes. With the 4H candle they react 68 / 79%. Against it, 47 / 29%.

Runs are 2 BCs long

After 10:00 a run makes a median 2 body closes and 30–36 pts (5m) before the other side closes. Take points; the opposite candle gives them back.

No trade by itself

The first BC after 10:00 with a 50 pt stop at 1:2 has no edge (t-score under 2). These are maps of the morning, not entries.

0

The data and the rulesRead this first

  • 2022–25 = NQ 1-minute data, Dec 2022 to Dec 2025, 763 trading days. This is where the numbers come from.
  • 2026 = MNQ 1-minute data, Mar–May and Sep–Oct 2026, 61 days. A fresh check. Small sample: treat 2026 as a guess when n is under 30.
  • Every result is written 2022–25 / 2026. Example: 83 / 85% = 83% in 2022–25 and 85% in 2026.
  • All times are New York. Weekdays only. Days with a missing 1m bar between 09:30 and 09:59 were skipped.
  • The window ends at 11:30, the moment Max stops trading.
  • Candles are read with MMM Candle Bias: each candle compared with the one before it. TGT (target) = the lean-side extreme. Protected = the other end.
  • Parts 1 to 8 count what price does. They are not tested strategies. Part 9 is a real trade test with a 1 point cost.
1

When the morning high and low are made09:30 to 11:30, by 15-minute slot

Median 09:30–11:30 range
154.8 / 234.5 pts
High or low in by 10:00
83.1 / 85.2%
11:30 closes above 09:30
51.5 / 52.5%
High made before the low
49.9 / 49.2%
SlotHigh made here %Low made here %
09:30–09:4532.4 / 29.532 / 32.8
09:45–10:008.8 / 9.813.1 / 16.4
10:00–10:159.4 / 13.111.8 / 3.3
10:15–10:307.6 / 6.66.2 / 9.8
10:30–10:455.4 / 8.27.2 / 4.9
10:45–11:007.5 / 3.37.2 / 13.1
11:00–11:159.2 / 8.29.8 / 11.5
11:15–11:3019.8 / 21.312.7 / 8.2
  • The first 15 minutes make the morning extremes. About 30–33% of highs and lows, 3 to 4 times a middle slot.
  • By 10:00, one side of the morning is usually done (83 / 85%). Both extremes after 10:00 is rare (17 / 15%).
  • 11:15–11:30 is the second slot for the high (20 / 21%): strong mornings often push into 11:30.
  • Up or down is a coin flip (51 / 53% up). The open does not tell you the side by itself.
2

The 09:30 opening candleThe first 5m or 15m candle, until 11:30

CandlenShare %Next candle TGT first %TGT before protected %11:30 closes its way %
5m · BC+180 / 1523.6 / 24.685 / 86.791.1 / 93.352.8 / 66.7
5m · BC−125 / 1216.4 / 19.747.2 / 33.363.2 / 33.354.4 / 75
5m · C2308 / 2440.4 / 39.374 / 66.782.1 / 79.249.7 / 54.2
5m · S&D84 / 511 / 8.263.1 / 8066.7 / 8045.2 / 80
5m · AFs61 / 58 / 8.268.9 / 10072.1 / 10027.9 / 60
15m · BC+170 / 622.3 / 9.882.4 / 10087.1 / 10054.7 / 100
15m · BC−122 / 916 / 14.850.8 / 66.763.9 / 77.854.1 / 44.4
15m · C2294 / 3038.5 / 49.272.8 / 76.783.7 / 8055.1 / 53.3
15m · S&D117 / 715.3 / 11.554.7 / 57.164.1 / 71.447.9 / 71.4
15m · AFs59 / 97.7 / 14.878 / 88.978 / 88.952.5 / 33.3
  • C2 is the most common opening candle (about 40%): the pre-open candle is small, so the open takes both of its sides.
  • BC+ is the cleanest: the next candle takes its target first 82–87%, and the target comes before the protected end 87–93%.
  • No opening candle tells you the 11:30 close (about 50% in 2022–25). Use it for the first push only.
3

The 30-minute opening rangeThe 09:30–10:00 high and low

Median range
94.2 / 167.2 pts
Closed out by 11:30
94.4 / 91.8%
First close out up / down
49.5 up · 44.8 down / 54.1 · 37.7
Run past the edge, median
51 / 70.8 pts
Closed out of the other side too
14.4 / 10.7%
11:30 still past that edge
56.9 / 62.5%
  • Price almost always leaves the range before 11:30 (94 / 92%), and the side is about 50/50.
  • The first close out usually holds: only 14 / 11% of days close out of the other side too, and 57 / 63% end 11:30 past the first edge.
  • Think of the range as a door: wait for the first 1m close through it, then expect about 51 / 71 pts more.
4

The candle that closes at 10:00How often the next candle takes the lean-side extreme FIRST (%)

CandleBC+ bullBC+ bearBC− bullBC− bearC2 bullC2 bear
4H 06:00–10:0090.5 / 77.8 *86.7 / 7549.3 / 77.8 *45.5 / 40 *84.9 / 100 *77.3 / 100 *
1h 09:00–10:0090.7 / 90.986.4 / 100 *50.9 / 50 *47.2 / 25 *78.7 / 100 *73 / 66.7 *
15m 09:45–10:0092.4 / 94.189 / 77.8 *57.6 / 33.3 *42.1 / 33.3 *100 / 100 *77.8 / 100 *
5m 09:55–10:0088.8 / 93.385.5 / 71.4 *61.4 / 0 *54.2 / 50 *91.7 / 0 *75 / 100 *

* = fewer than 10 cases in 2026.

  • BC+ works on every timeframe: 86–92% in 2022–25. The close sits next to the target, like a ball already at the door.
  • BC− is a coin flip (42–61%). The close position matters more than the body close.
  • The 10:00 lean does not tell you the 16:00 close (about 50–60%). Trade the morning, not the day.
5

UPG gaps made 09:30–10:003-candle gaps: touch, fill, react or fail

Gapsn gapsTouched %Median minutes to touchFull fill %React %
5m all1119 / 9082.5 / 73.35 / 3.573.9 / 66.763.3 / 68.2
1m all4767 / 40092.5 / 91.81 / 187.9 / 87.261 / 62.7
5m gap WITH 4H 06–10 lean910 / 7679.9 / 68.470.5 / 60.567.7 / 78.8
5m gap AGAINST 4H 06–10 lean209 / 1493.8 / 10088.5 / 10046.9 / 28.6
1m gap WITH 4H 06–10 lean3147 / 27190.1 / 88.284.3 / 82.767.6 / 71.5
1m gap AGAINST 4H 06–10 lean1620 / 12997.3 / 99.294.8 / 96.949.1 / 46.1
  • Opening gaps get touched fast: 5m 83 / 73%, median 5 / 4 minutes. A gap is a sponge: price comes back to soak it up.
  • Trade the gaps that point with the 4H 06–10 candle: react 68 / 79%. Against it only 47 / 29%.
  • Most gaps get fully filled later (5m 74 / 67%). A react is often a bounce, not the end.
6

An open gap on the other side of the 10:00 targetDoes price visit the gap behind it first? 10:00 to 11:30

10:00 candlenOpen gap there %Gap BEFORE the target %Target by 11:30 with the gap %
4H · strong (BC+ / C2)357 / 3188.8 / 96.818.9 / 2085.5 / 83.3
4H · weak406 / 3067.7 / 73.352 / 40.958.2 / 59.1
1h · strong (BC+ / C2)377 / 3386.2 / 87.922.2 / 17.287.4 / 93.1
1h · weak386 / 2859.6 / 67.944.8 / 47.466.1 / 57.9
15m · strong (BC+ / C2)227 / 2887.7 / 92.911.6 / 7.796 / 100
15m · weak536 / 3359.3 / 60.632.1 / 4584.9 / 65
5m · strong (BC+ / C2)227 / 2459 / 70.84.5 / 5.997 / 100
5m · weak536 / 3754.3 / 54.114.8 / 1093.5 / 90
  • A gap is usually there (56–78% of days) and it does not stop the target.
  • Strong candles ignore it: the gap comes first only 5% (5m) to 22% (1h).
  • Weak candles go there first 15% (5m), 32% (15m), 45% (1h), 52% (4H). On 1h and 4H, wait at the gap on those days.
7

From the first BC after 10:00 until the opposite candle or 11:30Body closes our way, NBCs, points, minutes

Chart · opposite ruleSame-side BCs (median)NBCs (average)MFE median ptsPoints at the end (average)Still alive at 11:30 %Minutes (median)
1m · opposite BC2 / 22.9 / 2.814 / 16-1.9 / -7.60 / 05 / 6
1m · close past BC low2 / 23.8 / 3.715.2 / 17.8-1.9 / -6.30 / 06 / 6
5m · opposite BC2 / 22.9 / 2.829.8 / 36.5-0.2 / -1.93.5 / 4.925 / 25
5m · close past BC low2 / 23.9 / 435.8 / 45.51.3 / 3.311.4 / 16.435 / 35
15m · opposite BC2 / 21.7 / 1.636 / 55.8-0.5 / -2.146.9 / 46.760 / 60
15m · close past BC low2 / 21.9 / 1.836.2 / 55.8-0.3 / 2.362.5 / 63.375 / 60
Chart (close past BC low)10 pts %20 pts %30 pts %50 pts %80 pts %
1m63.7 / 68.943 / 47.531.1 / 39.315.9 / 24.65.8 / 13.1
5m80.6 / 85.267.9 / 80.355.7 / 67.237.6 / 47.522.3 / 36.1
15m83.2 / 9069.5 / 86.758.6 / 73.335.8 / 56.720.2 / 40

Same-side BCs count the first BC. Opposite BC = the first body close the other way. Close past BC low = a close below the low of the last bull BC (bear: above the high of the last bear BC). The second table = how often the run gave X points our way before it ended.

  • Runs are short: median 2 same-side BCs on every chart, with about 3 NBCs (5m) or 2 (15m) in between.
  • The points are there, the exit is late: MFE median 30–36 pts on 5m, 36 pts on 15m, but at the opposite candle the average is about 0.
  • Take points before the other side closes: on 5m, 20 pts came 68 / 80% of the time, 30 pts 56 / 67%.
  • "Close past BC low" holds the longest. The 4H lean does not change the run.
8

5m BC runs by the hour they startEvery run in the data

Run starts inn runsBCs (average)Only 1 BC %Median pts to the run extreme
Asia 18:00-02:0013717 / 10732.4 / 2.540.5 / 39.46.5 / 15.2
London 02:00-08:0010536 / 8242.5 / 2.538.9 / 40.310 / 17.5
pre 08:00-09:302777 / 2202.5 / 2.439.4 / 39.515 / 26.8
NY AM 09:30-11:303470 / 2962.5 / 2.539.2 / 38.226.6 / 41.1
midday 11:30-14:004162 / 3522.6 / 2.339.4 / 4218.5 / 26
NY PM 14:00-16:003269 / 2732.5 / 2.539.7 / 38.118.2 / 26.8
after 16:00-18:001486 / 1322.3 / 2.240.6 / 44.78.2 / 14.8
  • Same count, bigger steps: 09:30–11:30 runs have the same number of BCs as other hours, but travel more points (27 / 41 pts median).
9

The trade test: 50 pt stop at 1:2Entry at the first BC after 10:00, target 100, out at 11:30, 1 pt cost

Chart · groupnWR = win rate %avg RRPF = profit factort-score
5m · all763 / 6146 / 36.1+0.06 / -0.091.1 / 0.91.5 / -0.5
5m · with the 4H lean413 / 3047.2 / 36.7+0.08 / -0.121.2 / 0.81.4 / -0.5
5m · first BC is a BC+414 / 3747.1 / 35.1+0.09 / -0.141.2 / 0.81.6 / -0.7
15m · all743 / 5944.8 / 42.4+0.02 / +0.051.1 / 1.10.6 / 0.3
15m · with the 4H lean430 / 3245.6 / 37.5+0.01 / -0.131 / 0.80.2 / -0.7
15m · first BC is a BC+454 / 3446.9 / 50+0.03 / +0.291.1 / 1.70.5 / 1.3

avg RR = average result in stops (1 = one 50 pt stop). PF = money won ÷ money lost. t-score of 2 or more = probably not luck.

  • No edge. Every t-score is under 2. The best row (15m, the first BC is a BC+) made +0.03 / +0.29 avg RR with t-score 0.5 / 1.3: that could be luck. The first BC after 10:00 is where you start counting, not an entry.
10

Best read per timeframe

4H
  • A BC+ at 10:00: target first 87–90% (75–78% in 2026).
  • Weak 4H candle: the gap behind it comes first 52%. Wait there.
  • Pullback when the lean is right: median 34 / 65 pts, mostly before 10:30.
1h
  • BC+: target first 86–91%.
  • Weak 1h candle: gap or target is a coin flip.
15m
  • The best balance. BC+: target first 89–92%.
  • Runs after 10:00: about half still alive at 11:30.
  • 20 pts reached 70 / 87%, 30 pts 59 / 73%.
5m
  • The fastest. BC+: target first 86–89%.
  • Opening gaps react 68 / 79% with the 4H lean.
  • Runs end in 25–35 minutes. 20 pts reached 68 / 80%.
11

How to use it from 09:30 to 11:30A reading order built from these counts, not a tested strategy

  1. Before 09:30Note the 4H 06:00–10:00 candle forming and any open UPG gaps from the night. The 4H side is the filter for the opening gaps.
  2. 09:30–10:00Expect the morning high or low to be made here (about 1 day in 3 in the first 15 minutes). Read the 09:30 5m / 15m candle: a BC+ shows the first push. Mark the 09:30–10:00 range.
  3. 09:30–10:00 gapsA 5m gap that points WITH the 4H candle reacts 68 / 79% of the time. Against it, it fails more often than it holds.
  4. 10:00Read the candles that close at 10:00. BC+ → its target is likely next. BC− → no side. Weak 1h or 4H candle → price often visits the open gap behind it first.
  5. 10:00–11:30Count the run: about 2 BCs and 2–3 NBCs, then the other side closes. Take points (20–30 on 5m / 15m) before the opposite candle. Use "close past the BC low" as the line that ends the run.
  6. 11:30Stop. Most mornings already made their range, and the 10:00 lean says nothing about 16:00.
12

What does NOT work

  • The 10:00 lean to call the 16:00 close (about 50–60%).
  • A BC− candle for direction (coin flip).
  • Holding until the opposite candle: the run gives the points back (average about 0 at the exit).
  • The first BC after 10:00 as an entry with a 50 pt stop at 1:2 (no edge, t-score under 2).
  • Guessing the side of the opening range before the first close out of it (about 50/50).
13

Words used

BC
Body close: the candle closes past the previous candle’s high (bull) or low (bear). Urgency.
NBC
No body close: the candle closes inside the previous candle. Negotiation.
BC+ / BC−
A BC that closes in its strong quarter (+) or not (−).
C2
The candle takes the other side first, then closes through: an engulf.
AFs / CI / S&D
Sweep and close back inside / inside candle / takes both sides and closes inside.
TGT / protected
TGT = the lean-side extreme of the candle. Protected = the other end.
UPG gap
A 3-candle gap: candle 3 never comes back to candle 1’s high (bull).
MFE
The most points in our favour before the end.
Opening range
The high and low of 09:30–10:00.